Sirloin Vs Ribeye: An Ultimate Comparison

A simple life fact is that most humans like to eat meat. Historically humans began eating meat because it was considered as high-energy food and very beneficial for brain development.  We also eat it because it is culturally significant and a status symbol of a sort. For example, people in rich Western countries eat much more meat than people in poor African nations! Finally, we eat it because we enjoy the taste of it.

Among different types of meat, steak is undeniably the most popular. While traveling around the world you may find it difficult to find a place that serves a good lamb or pork. But you will find steakhouses even in the smallest towns.  Whenever people think about eating a delicious piece of meat, they have steak in mind. When you are organizing a party, you are more likely to serve steak than chicken or fish, right? But do you know that there is more than one type of steak? For example, some like ribeye, while others prefer sirloin. But do you know the difference between ribeye and sirloin? Now you will!

What is a Sirloin Steak?

The Sirloin steak, aka Porterhouse steak, New York strip, or Striploin Steak, is one of the most common beef cuts. Of the two loin subprimal, sirloin is the one farther back in the cow’s back leg. In other words, it is a part of the leg that gets more exercise. This meat can be tougher than cuts from the front part of the loin. It is, however, very rich in flavor and perfect for grilling and BBQing. 

Another important thing about this meat is that it’s always boneless. However, there is a version of sirloin steak with a bone. Some people call it Short loin. However, it is most popular as T – bone steak.

Nutrition Total amount (3-ounce serving) % Daily value
Calories 150 8
Saturated Fat 1.9 10
Protein 26 g 52
Iron 1.6mg 10
Zinc 4.8mg 30%

How to Cook a Sirloin Steak?

Sirloin steak is best cooked on a hot grill.  The burners on one side of the grill should be set on medium heat and low on the other.  If you are using a charcoal grill, you should use 2 zone grilling. Grill the steak for 3 minutes on one side and then flip to another. After that, you can move to an indirect heat zone. If you want the steak more cooked, you can leave it on the indirect side until it’s done how you like it.

What is a Ribeye Steak?

Ribeye steaks are sometimes called beauty steaks. They are tender, juicy, flavorful, and come with the right amount of fat. These steaks can be with or without a bone. And the bone adds flavor and moisture. However, it can be more challenging to cook a steak with the bone. 

The main muscle in this steak is the longissimus dorsi. It is a very tender muscle since it doesn’t get a lot of exercise.

Nutrition Total Amount per 3 ounces % Daily value
Calories 190 10
Saturated fat 4g 20
Sodium 60mg 3
Protein 23g 46
Iron 2.2mg 10
Zinc 5mg 35

How to Cook Ribeye Steak?

The best way to cook it is on high heat. You can do it on a grill, cast iron skillet, or under a broiler. As a result, you will have a piece of meat with wonderful crust. However, it will be tender and juicy on the inside. Keep in mind that the grill or the pan needs to be super hot before you add the meat. Remember to brush the meat with oil. If you are cooking a 1.5-inch steak, you will need between three and five minutes for medium-rare.  Ideally, you should use a thermometer and remove the meat when it reaches 130 to 135 degrees Fahrenheit. Them, wait between 5-10 minutes before serving.

Sirloin vs. Ribeye: In-Depth Comparison

Okay, now we know more about sirloin and ribeye and how to cook them. But some of you may still wonder about the differences between them. In this part, we are going to show you the ribeye vs sirloin difference so you can order exactly what you want next time you eat out.

Cut Size Meat content Fat content Average weight Serving per cut Location on cow
Sirloin Medium to large Very meaty Low to moderate fat 6 -10 ounces 1 Loin primal top or bottom
Ribeye Medium to large Very meaty Moderate to High fat 8 -12 ounces 2 Upper central ribs

Meat, Fat Content and Health Benefits

Even if they may appear similar to inexperienced steak eaters, you can see that there is a clear difference when it comes to fat content. So when you are choosing between sirloin or ribeye you need to ask yourself do you want leaner or fattier meat. Studies show lean meat is way healthier and reduces the risk of diabetes and heart disease. If you pay attention to health and fitness, you should opt for top sirloin vs ribeye at any time.   The meat content is pretty much the same.


Flavor generally depends on the amount of fat. Hence the ribeye is more flavorful because it has more marbling than the sirloin. However, if you prefer leaner meat, you will enjoy sirloin steak more.

Texture & Appearance

Maybe you are wondering which is more tender sirloin or ribeye? Generally, we would say that ribeye is softer because of the fat. However, the dry-aging process makes meat tenderers, so now we can find plenty of equally tender sirloin steaks.

Portion Sizes

When deciding which is better ribeye or sirloin, you have to consider the portion size. When you order sirloin, you get only one piece of meat. With ribeye, you get two steaks. If you are really hungry, this is the better option. It is the same when deciding about types of beef roasts.


The price of the steak can vary significantly. Several factors can impact the price. The most important are a breed of animal, weight, and USDA rating. However, in general, you will have to pay more for the steak that comes with more marbling.


You have noticed that these are two pretty different cuts of meat. Hence you have to prepare them in different ways. The good thing is that there are many options for preparing each of them.

Which is better for Different Cooking Styles?

Which is Better for Grilling?

When it comes to grilling, there is no winner between these two steaks. They both taste amazing when grilled. Some grill lovers prefer sirloin because it contains less fat and it is cheaper.  It is also somewhat smaller than ribeye, which makes it more convenient for a family BBQ.

Which is Better for Smoking?

Again it is the question of personal preference. Many people prefer sirloin as one of best meats to smoke because it doesn’t come with a lot of fat, and the cuts are smaller. However, if you like fattier meat, then you will enjoy smoked ribeye steak.

Which is Easier to Cook and Best for a Beginner?

Generally, both cuts are easy to cook regardless of whether you are a beginner or not. You don’t need to trim or marinade them. Sirloin steak cooks quicker because it is smaller and has less fat. People like to have some fat on their steaks because it makes them juicer and more tender. However, theft can drip in the grill and cause flare-ups. If you don’t have any experience, this can be challenging to handle. Hence for beginners, it is better to start with sirloin steaks.


That is all about sirloin vs. ribeye for today, folks! As you could see, these are both delicious cuts of meat, and there isn’t a really straightforward answer as to which one is better. However, keep in mind that sirloin steaks are better for small family gatherings and beginner grillers. And if you are hosting a big party, it may be better to cook ribeye steaks. 

So, have you cooked sirloin or ribeye before? Which one do you prefer and why?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *